- D. Donovan, senior reviewer Midwest Book Review
- Vincent Czyz received the 2016 Eric Hoffer Award for Best in Small Press for Adrift in a Vanishing City.
- Erol Engin's The Sea Monkeys won the Page Seventeen Short Story Contest in 2012.
- Lilla Glass earned a Silver Honorable Mention in the Writers of the Future Winter 2021 Quarter competition for her short story Best Spuds.
- Bradley Harper's debut, A Knife in the Fog, was a finalist for a 2019 Edgar Award by the Mystery Writers of America for Best First Novel by an American Author and won Killer Nashville's 2019 Silver Falchion as Best Mystery. The sequel, Queen's Gambit, won Killer Nashville's 2020 Silver Falchion Award twice-for both Best Suspense and Book of the Year.
- Derek McFadden's What Death Taught Terrence was a 2021 Next Generation Indie Book Award Finalist and a Silver Medal winner at the 2021 Wishing Shelf Book Awards.